Failed Olympic Events
Monday, September 27th, 2004Do you know what is absurd? Some of these failed Olympic events.
Actually, it’s not just the failed ones that baffle me, but some of the accepted one as well.
In the last couple of decades we’ve seen team rhythmic gymnastics added to the Olympics, along with beach volleyball, triathlon, trampoline, tae kwon do and women’s wrestling.
I left out synchronized diving because that deserves to be a sport more than synch swimming and I’m trying to limit the scope of the argument. Now if the synch divers were only 4 feet apart or were tethered together… that would warrant inclusion.
The IOC has listened to talk of adding ‘recognized sports’ such as climbing, surfing, poker, bridge, chess, golf, bowling, squash, cricket, wushu, racquetball, billiards and extreme sport variations like skateboarding and something called half-pipe. I can only assume the last of that group is an inside joke to the preferred ‘training supplement’ of the skateboarders, so we’ll dismiss that one and focus on the remainder.
If you don’t know Wushu, check http://www.china.org.cn/english/2001/Dec/24469.htm
The third group considered is made up of sports that were once in the Games, but are no longer contested. These include Tug-O-War, Golf, Rugby, Polo and Lacrosse.
What exactly makes one of the above a sport and not the others? Beats me. Why should one or any of them be kept or bumped? Beats me. Let’s handle this in the only fair way, the way men would handle most situations if they could – lump the best from every group into the arena, a giant steel-cage brawl and see which sports come out on top in the various categories and which end up dead as a doornail. And, like that expression, some of these events may be just as severely outdated.
The Categories shall be the Newly Added, the Potentials and the Used-to-Be.
How do we rate? We use specially ‘non-IOC recognized’ categories. The categories are
Physical Prowess, Mental Prowess, TV Appeal, Sex Appeal, Cereal Box Hero, Chance for Injury, Similarity to Existing Sport and Comedy. Rather than gives scores with have to be tabulated (and that’s too much work) I will simply rate everything as plus/minus.
First up, Physical Prowess. Simply put, we think the Olympics are about people who look Olympian, or at a minimum, look moderately fit. You don’t have to look like Jennie Finch or Matt Biondi just so long as your body isn’t beyond-i repulsive. Mostly you just have to be physically adept to compete in your sport. Beer swilling may not be a sport, but running is.
Winners: beach volleyball, triathlon, gymnastics, wushu, skateboarding, tug-o-war and rugby.
Among the Losers: Trampoline, Bowling and Poker all falling into the “it doesn’t matter what you look like since you can still do it” realm. For that, they get a minus.
Close call: Golf. While it takes coordination to strike the ball, I believe that with enough practice anyone can do it and its all club technology nowadays anyway. Sorry, duffers.
Next, Mental Prowess. Does this sport require any brain power at all?
Winners: Triathlon, poker and chess. Everything else fails in this category. What kind of frontal lobe activity does it take to play polo? You get on the horse and ride. Honestly.
Rugby? I think having a weaker brain may actually be a benefit, not a hazard.
Third is TV Appeal. Nothing succeeds if it doesn’t look good on TV.
Winners: Trampoline, skateboarding and golf. Watching anyone do the trampoline is silly, but still fun, skateboarding already gets good TV ratings even in the wee hours and golf does well with almost any tournament involving a player named after an animal.
Losers: Poker, chess, tug-o-war, tae kwon do. I know poker is on every channel (including the new Animal Planet’s ‘Chimps with Chips’ series) but poker is fun to play, lame to watch. Watching chess? It’s rough enough to watch a chess game that you’re actually playing. Unless your name is White or Black, chess is a no-go on TV. Tae Kwon Do fails because nothing happens as the players position themselves and then, in a split-second, they attack, and it’s over. This means you have to watch every second to see the action. Humans like a break between plays or shots or hits to relax and eat more nachos. Sorry, but the only Tae I want to see on television is named Kobe and that’s an entirely different kind of event.
Sex Appeal is simple: we like pretty athletes, sports, uniforms and our stars on magazines.
Winners: Beach volleyball (bikinis), rugby (tight pants), lacrosse (preppy collegians)
Losers: The rhythmic gymnasts are surprise losers in that they aren’t women – they are girls. As soon as they hit puberty and start to look like women, they’re long past their prime for the sport they play. Thus, denial. Skateboarding fails as well – no one looks sexy wearing a crash-test dummy helmet and elbow pads. I don’t care how many flips you just did.
Half-way through and only bowling and tae kwon do are minus in every category.
Cereal Box means that your sport needs someone who can stand out and be recognized for marketing and not just on a cereal box – your sport has a potential social representative.
Winners: Everyone but lacrosse. They wear cages and huge masks. You don’t even know which players you’re rooting for. I’m sorry, but a stick with a net on it has a bigger following.
More importantly, name any lacrosse player besides Jim Brown. You win a cookie if you could have named him before I did. To collect your cookie, call your mom.
Sick as it is, everyone likes to see a car crash. Chance of Injury is a factor that must be included in any sporting argument. Watching it happen to someone else – we can’t resist.
Winners: Trampoline, rugby, polo. Any event where you can get dragged along by a horse all over the field can do well in the ratings. Ruggers lose their teeth and the trampoline throws you into the air. Just sit back, relax and let gravity do the work. The best way to cause more injuries in trampoline is to do it synchronized. Two people, one trampoline.
On the fence: Wushu. Do you have any doubt that a sport based upon sword-wielding can’t get a bit messy? If you want to see that, rent Kill Bill. Athletes chopping at each other with swords isn’t a sport – it’s just creepy. Still, I must grudgingly admit, if I heard that the North Korean kid suffered a lacerated spleen, I’d probably tune in for it; thus, wushu gets a plus.
Among the losers: name your favorite chess injury. Other than Anthony Edwards in Revenge of the Nerds II and that shouldn’t count because they didn’t even show it.
Similarity to Existing Olympic Sports is usually a springboard for future inclusion.
Winners: Beach volleyball (volleyball), Triathlon (marathon), Tae Kwon Do (judo), Gymnastics, and Lacrosse (combining soccer, tennis, water polo and team handball).
Losers: Bowling. Is this archery with a 10 pound arrow?
Another loser: Poker. No Olympic card games yet, so it’s tough to set the backdrop for breaking into this virgin territory. Same goes for checkers, backgammon and cribbage.
The final category is Comedy. Wacky sports are just fun to watch.
Winners: Trampoline, bowling, skateboard, and tug-o-war.
Bowling is funny because they take themselves seriously. Tugging? Just to see the endorsement deals and advertising the various ‘athletes’ would wear. Glue? Cement?
Poly-Grip?
The final tally?
Phys Mental TV Sex Wheat Injury Similar Comedy Points
Beach VB + - + + + - + 5
Triathlon + + - - + + + - 5
Trampoline - - + - + + - + 4
Taekwondo - - - - + + + 3
Rhy.Gym. + - - - + - + - 3
Bowling - - - - + - - + 2
Poker - + - - + - - 2
Chess - + - - + - - 2
Skateboard + - + - + + - + 5
Wushu + - + - + + - 4
Tug-o-War + - - - + - - + 3
Golf - - + - + - - 2
Rugby + - - + + + - 3
Polo - - + - + + - 3
Lacrosse - - - + - - + 2
Beach volleyball, triathlon and trampoline maintain their status, but tae kwon do and rhythmic gymnastics should be revoked.
Skateboarding and wushu earn their stripes, but the other potentials… well, they have no potential.
Expired sports like tug-o-war, rugby and polo come close, but if you can’t pull a 50-50 split in the categories, you can’t get added to the great list of events.
There’s the final tally – We add two sports and drop two sports so it comes out even steven.
What could be more absurd than that?
